American Thinker: D'Souza's "Death of a Nation" stands up to criticism

Originally posted at American Thinker by Richard Kirk.

Rule of thumb: If Rotten Tomatoes and most movie critics hate a political flick, it must be good! One of those critics who hangs out at the website deemed Dinesh D’Souza’s latest film, Death of a Nation, so “shabbily constructed and artistically bankrupt” that it hardly “qualifies as a movie in the first place.” Peter Sobczynski doesn’t deal seriously with the film’s core assertions, which he cavalierly dismisses as “cherry-picked facts” garnished by “overt omissions.”

Those two terms do serve well, alongside “blatant distortions,” as descriptions of Sobczynski’s review. D’Souza’s movie, for example, compares Donald Trump to Abraham Lincoln only in certain respects, primarily as an American president who faces tremendous political hostility that once again threatens to divide the Union. P.S. repeats a canard that D’Souza has repeatedly demolished, including in this film, that the parties “switched positions” with respect to civil rights in the 1960s. This widely accepted misrepresentation ignores the fact that a greater percentage of Republicans than Democrats supported the ’64 Civil Rights bill (which was filibustered in the Senate by Southern Democrats) and that all but two of the hundreds of segregationist Dixiecrat legislators remained Democrats throughout their long careers, including former Klansman Senator Robert Byrd of West Virginia. D’Souza also notes that the Democrat George Wallace carried the Deep South in 1968, not Richard Nixon, whose Civil Rights initiatives are rigorously ignored by leftist historians and movie critics who incessantly push the “Southern strategy” narrative.

P.S. also ignores the boatload of historical cherries that clearly put Mussolini’s fascism on the “left” or socialist side of the political spectrum and has nothing to say about its curious “right-wing” repositioning after World War II. Hitler, like Mussolini, was a national socialist. D’Souza provides in this film several additional “cherries” that illuminate the mutual admiration that existed for years between Mussolini and FDR, as well as a few nuggets that show embarrassing links between Germany’s early Nazi years and Roosevelt’s New Deal. If P.S. has any intellectual curiosity about such things, it isn’t communicated in his epithet-laden review. For those individuals who might be interested, D’Souza provides reams of additional evidence about the leftist origins of fascism in his book The Big Lie.

Other “cherries” P.S. “overtly omits” from his review include the re-segregation of the White House by President Woodrow Wilson, that same Progressive Democrat’s White House screening of D.W. Griffith’s Klan-boosting The Birth of a Nation, and the blatantly racist aspects of Margaret Sanger’s progressive eugenics-based organization, Planned Parenthood. Needless to say, P.S. has nothing positive to say about Trump and adds for his mindless readers that D’Souza never mentions “the countless [unspecified] scandals surrounding the administration.”

From my own perspective, Death of a Nation does cover much of the material that was dealt with in D’Souza’s prior films, but this “repetitious” objection doesn’t seem to count against the hundreds of Watergate or McCarthy-era retellings that continue to titillate Democrats and the mainstream media.  Moreover, it certainly takes more than a few reiterations to drive home points that counter well established lies like “the parties switched in the ’60s” and “fascism is on the right.” Another important point the film makes is that northern Democrats opposed the 13th, 14th, and 15th amendments to the Constitution that outlawed slavery and granted citizenship and voting rights to blacks. Consequently, the Civil War was not just a war of North versus South, but, in some respects, a war of anti-slavery Republicans against pro-slavery (or anti-abolition) Democrats who resided in both the North and the South.

A completely new component of D’Souza’s recent film is his interview with a white supremacist leader, Richard Spencer, whose favorite presidents include the founder of the Democratic Party, Andrew Jackson, and expansionist Democrat slave-owner James Polk. Far from being a conservative, Spencer sees rights being bestowed on us by “the state” and not “by God or nature.” P.S. writes in his review that D’Souza “twists things around” to get Spencer to say “I guess I’m a Progressive,” but what D’Souza actually does is point out how Spencer’s political beliefs coincide with the state-centered philosophy of Progressivism. The mainstream media portray Spencer as a leader of the “Alt-Right” animated by President Trump, who, despite media claims, has actually pursued a non-state-centered agenda.

For those of us who have seen D’Souza’s prior films, Death of a Nation may seem like more of the same, even if “the same” is stuff that’s essential to the nation’s survival. For those who aren’t familiar with D’Souza’s work, Death of a Nation could be a revelatory moment that turns their political world upside-down. At the very least, for those folks whose minds are at all open, it can be an invitation to explore whether ideas that most folks take for granted are actually true—and if they aren’t true, how and by whom those lies came to be propagated.

Read more at American Thinker.


Available for pre-order now, Dinesh D’Souza’s new book United States of Socialism reveals modern-day socialism as a “identity socialism.” Who is behind it, why is it evil, and how can we stop it?

United States of Socialism

Click here to be the first to get your copy before it releases on June 2, 2020!

Keep reading:

The Hill: Lincoln's know-nothing strategy a lesson for Trump
Rush Limbaugh: D'Souza on his new provocative new film and the fascism of the Democratic Party
VIDEO: D'Souza and Jesse Lee Peterson debunk the lie that Trump is a racist
American Greatness: Richard Spencer, Wilsonian Progressive
VIDEO: Why are Democrats still nuts 2 years after Trump's win?
WND: D'Souza unleashes on his movie critics
EXCLUSIVE MOVIE CLIP: Conclusive proof Nazism is on the Left
VIDEO: D'Souza joins Joe Pags to discuss why the Left is terrified of "Death of a Nation"

Through D'Souza's trademark incisiveness, wit, and originality, United States of Socialism reveals how the Left uses the Venezuelan formula for socialism, decisively refutes this new face of socialism, chillingly documents the full range of the Left’s gangster tendencies, and provocatively exposes the tactics of the socialist Left.

Sign up to be notified about new releases! Enter your email below and we'll send you more information.

By filling out the form above, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.